The Guardian Biggest Football Talents: How the List Shapes the Future of the Game
The Guardian’s annual “Biggest Football Talents” ranking has become a benchmark for scouting, media, and fans alike. By combining expert opinion with statistical analysis, the list highlights players who are already making an impact and those poised to become the next generation of super‑stars. This article explains the methodology behind the ranking, profiles recent winners such as Ousmane Dembélé and Aitana Bonmatí, and explores why the list matters for clubs, coaches, and the wider football community.
How The Guardian Selects Its Biggest Football Talents
Expert panel of 197 judges
A panel of 197 judges—including former internationals, coaches, and analysts—provides the backbone of the selection process. Legends of the game such as Leonardo Bonucci and Philipp Lahm sit alongside emerging scouts, ensuring a balanced perspective that values both experience and contemporary insight.
Criteria and voting process
Each judge evaluates candidates on a set of transparent criteria:
- Current performance in club and international competition
- Technical skill and versatility
- Impact on match outcomes
- Potential for growth over the next three to five years
Judges submit their verdicts independently, and the aggregated scores determine the final ranking. The process mirrors the rigorous standards seen in other Guardian awards, reinforcing credibility and reducing bias.
Recent Winners and Rising Stars
Ousmane Dembélé: Seventh Winner
French winger Ousmane Dembélé became the seventh winner on the list, surpassing Lamine Yamal (second) and Vitinha (third). Dembélé’s blend of pace, dribbling, and finishing has earned him a regular spot in the French national team and a pivotal role at his club. His inclusion underscores the
